Overview
Payment shock in Canada refers to a sudden, significant increase in mortgage payments, most commonly experienced at mortgage renewal when interest rates have risen since the original loan was taken out. With a large proportion of Canadians facing mortgage renewals in 2025 and beyond, payment shock is a growing concern, especially for those who secured low rates during the COVID-19 pandemic and are now renewing at much higher rates.
What Is Payment Shock?
- Definition: Payment shock occurs when a homeowner’s mortgage payment rises sharply, typically due to higher interest rates at renewal or changes in adjustable-rate mortgage terms.
- Causes:
- Rising interest rates since initial mortgage or last renewal.
- Renewing mortgages taken at historically low rates (2020–2022) at today’s higher rates.
- Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARM) where payments fluctuate with the lender’s prime rate.
- Variable-rate mortgages with fixed payments, where the portion applied to principal drops, and the payment may jump at renewal.
Current Market Conditions & Payment Shock Impact
- 2025–2026 Renewal Wave: About 60% of Canadian mortgages will renew by the end of 2026.
- Average Increase:
- Many homeowners are seeing mortgage payments rise by 25% or more at renewal.
- For example, a $400,000 mortgage at 2.65% (2020) renewing at 4.1% results in roughly a $300/month payment jump.
- In Ontario and BC, about 10% of borrowers renewing in 2024 saw payments rise by $500 or more per month.
- Regional Variations:
- Payment shock is more severe in high-priced markets like the Greater Toronto Area and Greater Vancouver Area.
- Financial Impact:
- Many homeowners are cutting discretionary spending and prioritizing mortgage payments over other debts.
- Defaults and arrears are rising, but still below pre-pandemic levels.
Bank and Regulator Responses
- Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI):
- Identifies payment shock as a major risk, particularly for highly leveraged borrowers and those with variable-rate, fixed-payment mortgages.
- Introduced loan-to-income (LTI) limits for uninsured mortgages to prevent excessive risk (max 4.5x borrower’s annual income).
- Maintains strict qualifying rate rules (greater of contract rate +2% or 5.25%) to ensure borrowers can withstand rate increases.
- Major Banks:
- Offering renewal advice and some flexibility, but payment increases are largely unavoidable if rates are higher at renewal.
- Options may include extending amortization (which reduces monthly payments but increases interest over time) or refinancing.
Provincial Considerations
- British Columbia:
- Payment shock is particularly acute due to high average home prices.
- Ontario:
- Similar stress in high-value markets.
- Other Provinces:
- Payment shock exists but may be less severe where home prices and average mortgage balances are lower.
Comparing Mortgage Types and Payment Shock Risk
| Mortgage Type | Payment Shock Risk at Renewal | Notes |
|---|
| Fixed-rate (5-year typical) | High | Payments jump sharply if rates are higher at renewal. |
| Adjustable-rate (ARM) | Immediate | Payments change with prime rate; shock felt as rates rise, not just at renewal. |
| Variable-rate, fixed payment | Very High at Renewal | Payment stays the same during term, but principal paid drops; big jump at renewal. |
Managing Payment Shock: Tips and Recommendations
- Start Budgeting Early: Anticipate payment increases and adjust discretionary spending now.
- Shop Around at Renewal: Compare rates and products from multiple lenders to find the best deal.
- Consider Amortization Extension: Reduces monthly payments, but increases total interest paid.
- Seek Professional Advice: Mortgage brokers can help navigate renewal options.
- Monitor Government Programs: Stay informed about federal or provincial relief measures if introduced.
For a comprehensive, personalized rate comparison and to start an application with access to top Canadian lenders, use theratefinder’s multi-step platform at theratefinder.ca/onboarding/email.
Summary & Next Steps
- Payment shock is a pressing issue for Canadian homeowners renewing mortgages in 2025–2026, with many facing increases of 25% or more in monthly payments due to higher interest rates.
- Homeowners in Ontario and BC are particularly affected due to high mortgage balances.
- Regulators are monitoring risks and banks are offering some flexibility, but preparation and early action are key.
- Actionable steps: Review your renewal date, start budgeting for higher payments, compare rates using platforms like theratefinder, and seek advice from a mortgage professional to mitigate payment shock and secure the best terms.